Capital City Mortgage, Mortgage Broker, Lincoln, Omaha, NE, Refinance, Lower Rate, Home Loan

(402)489-2099

Can You Change Home Insurance With a Mortgage

Can You Change Homeowners Insurance With a Mortgage?

Nov 17, 2026

You can change homeowners insurance companies while you have a mortgage. You are not required to stay with the insurance company you used when you purchased or refinanced the home. However, the replacement policy must meet the mortgage company’s coverage requirements, and the lender or loan servicer must receive the new policy information.

The process takes more coordination when insurance is paid through an escrow account. Homeowners should have the new policy active before canceling the old one. This avoids a lapse in coverage and helps prevent the mortgage servicer from purchasing expensive insurance on the homeowner’s behalf.

Why Homeowners Change Insurance Companies

A large premium increase is one of the most common reasons to shop for new insurance. Other homeowners want better customer service, a lower deductible, broader coverage, or a better price when home and auto policies are bundled.

Price should not be the only factor. A lower premium may come with a higher deductible, lower dwelling coverage, limited roof coverage, or new exclusions. Compare the same coverage limits and deductibles before deciding that one policy is a better value.

The condition of the home also matters. A recent roof replacement, electrical update, security system, or other improvement may affect pricing and eligibility. Tell the new insurance agent about major changes so the quote is based on accurate information.

Your Mortgage Company Still Has Requirements

A mortgage lender has a financial interest in the property. It will normally require homeowners insurance for as long as the mortgage remains on the home. The lender or servicer must also be listed correctly on the policy as the mortgagee.

The Nebraska Department of Insurance explains that mortgage lenders typically require homeowners insurance and may obtain coverage if a homeowner lets the policy lapse. Nebraska Department of Insurance The replacement policy should provide enough coverage to meet the loan requirements and protect the property.

Your new insurance agent may need the mortgagee clause. This is the mortgage company’s official name and mailing address for insurance purposes. It may be different from the address where mortgage payments are sent.

How to Change Homeowners Insurance With Escrow

When insurance is escrowed, part of each mortgage payment is placed into an account for property taxes and insurance. The mortgage servicer then pays the insurance bill when it becomes due.

Changing companies does not remove the escrow account. The servicer needs the new premium amount, effective date, declarations page, and billing information so it can update the account and send future payments to the correct company.

Buy the new policy first

Choose the replacement coverage and set its effective date before canceling the current policy. The new policy should begin no later than the date the old policy ends. An overlap of a day may be safer than leaving even a short gap.

Ask the new insurance agent to provide a declarations page or insurance binder. This document shows the coverage, premium, effective date, insured property, and mortgage company information.

Notify the mortgage servicer

Send the new policy documents to the department that monitors insurance. Many servicers have an online portal, email address, fax number, or third-party insurance website for this purpose.

Confirm that the documents were received and accepted. Do not assume the insurance agent’s submission completed the update. Continue checking until the servicer shows the correct company and policy.

Cancel the old policy

Cancel the former policy only after the new coverage is active. Ask the former insurer to confirm the cancellation date in writing.

You may receive a refund for the unused portion of the old premium. If the original premium was paid through escrow, ask the mortgage servicer how the refund should be handled. Keeping the refund may contribute to an escrow shortage because money from the account was used to pay the old premium.

Will Changing Insurance Affect the Mortgage Payment?

It can. The principal and interest portion of a fixed-rate mortgage does not change, but the escrow portion may change when the annual insurance premium changes.

A less expensive policy may eventually reduce the amount collected for insurance. A higher premium may increase it. The change may not appear immediately because servicers usually review the escrow account on a schedule.

The account may temporarily show an unusual balance when the new policy is paid before the old premium refund is returned. Keep copies of both policies, the cancellation notice, the refund, and all communications with the servicer.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recommends monitoring mortgage statements and insurance bills so escrow problems can be identified quickly. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Contact the servicer if the wrong insurer is paid or the escrow balance appears incorrect.

Avoid Force-Placed Insurance

If the mortgage servicer does not have proof of acceptable coverage, it may purchase force-placed insurance and charge the cost to the homeowner. This can happen because of a true lapse, an unpaid renewal, or missing policy documentation.

Force-placed coverage is usually more expensive and may protect only the lender’s interest in the structure. It may provide less protection for personal belongings, liability, or additional living expenses.

The CFPB advises homeowners with force-placed insurance to obtain acceptable coverage, send proof to the servicer, and request cancellation of the lender-purchased policy. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Federal servicing rules generally require the servicer to cancel force-placed coverage after receiving evidence of qualifying coverage and address charges for overlapping periods.

Can You Switch Insurance Before Closing?

A buyer may change insurance companies before closing, but the timing matters. The lender must review the replacement policy and confirm that it meets the loan requirements. Insurance costs also affect the final cash-to-close figures and the amount collected for escrow.

A last-minute switch may require updated disclosures or revised closing documents. Tell the loan officer and closing company before making the change. This gives everyone time to update the policy, premium, mortgagee clause, and payment information.

Pros and Cons of Switching

The main benefit is the possibility of better coverage, service, or pricing. Shopping may also identify missing protection or policy limits that no longer reflect the cost of rebuilding the home.

The drawback is the chance of creating a coverage gap, duplicate payment, or escrow shortage if the change is not coordinated. Cancellation fees may also apply depending on the insurance company and policy terms.

Who Should Review Their Coverage?

Homeowners should consider a review after a large renewal increase, major renovation, roof replacement, refinance, or change in how the property is used. It is also worth reviewing coverage when a policy contains limits or exclusions that are not clear.

Shopping is not the same as automatically changing companies. Compare the full policy and speak with a licensed insurance professional before making a decision.

Coordinate the Change Carefully

You have the right to shop for homeowners insurance while you have a mortgage. The important steps are keeping continuous coverage, meeting the lender’s requirements, updating the mortgage servicer, and handling any premium refund correctly.

Capital City Mortgage can help Nebraska homeowners understand how insurance and escrow affect their mortgage payment. For questions about coverage, limits, exclusions, or claims, work directly with a licensed insurance professional. Clear communication between the homeowner, insurance agent, and mortgage servicer can prevent most problems.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my mortgage company stop me from changing insurance companies?

The mortgage company generally cannot require you to use one specific insurer, but the replacement policy must meet the loan’s coverage requirements.

Should I cancel my old homeowners policy before buying a new one?

No. Put the replacement policy in effect first, then cancel the old policy so there is no gap in coverage.

What happens to my escrow account when I switch insurance?

The escrow account remains in place. The servicer updates the insurance premium and payment information, which may affect the escrow balance and future mortgage payment.

What should I do with a refund from my old insurance company?

Ask your mortgage servicer how the refund should be handled. If escrow paid the original premium, the servicer may want the refund deposited back into the escrow account.

Recent Posts

Ready to Explore Your Financing?

Get a personalized quote to see what loan options may be available for your situation.

Or call us directly:

  • 402-489-2099

Comparing Your Options?

Everyones financial circumstances and overall goals are different. Depending on your situation, a Conventional, FHA, VA,  USDA or other loans might offer the best advantage. We can help you understand how these options compare.